sweet music index

Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer

Date: Sunday, March 15, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DP 
I am curious if anyone uses an violin bow to play their dulcimer. If you do...what is your technique? what songs do you play?  

Date: Sunday, March 15, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: KD 
I use a psaltry bow sometimes, but not often. When performing I will usually only play one tune (if any at all). I just haven't mastered it well enough to do much more. I also demonstrate it to my students, but don't spend much time on using it.  

On a dulcimer you cannot play all three/four strings like you can on a violin/fiddle. (Because of string placement). You can however play using the treble string(s) and bass string.  

Also be aware that rosin is HORRIBLE for your wood. Also some of the rosin will stick to the strings affecting the tone somewhat. I am fortunate enough to have several dulcimers, so I use one of my inexpensive lease instruments for bowing, and I try to wipe the rosin off the wood as soon as possible. 

Date: Sunday, March 15, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: MJP 
I'm working at it. Can't say that I have gotten beyond the experimenting stage. It helps to have a shorter bow. I have a 3/4 bow that I bought second hand off a fiddle player. The idea is to bow across all three strings at the same time so that it sounds a lot like a bagpipe drone. This means that your strings must be all the same height. It works best if you bow about two inches from the bridge. It takes a lot of practice just getting a smooth back and forth action going before you can start playing any kind of melody. It's a bit hard to describe how to hold the bow. You kind of pinch it between you thumb and index and middle finger. You have to hold the bow a bit further toward the middle than where a fiddle player would hold it. Once you get a smooth action going and can play some tunes, you can try some double bowing which has a faster action on individual notes.  

If you ever have a chance to have David Schnaufer as a teacher, he knows how to bow. 

Date: Sunday, March 15, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: MT 
I have been in a room with 13 people bowing mountain dulcimers.....The Chinese are thinking of using it to replace the water torture....... 

Date: Monday, March 16, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DW 
This subject was well covered by Ms. P. The only workshops I have attended on bowing were; David Schnaufer and Mark Biggs. David bows all three strings, where Mark mostly the melody string. It is a style that takes a lot of work to perfect. As for the bow sizes, is up to the person. A psaltery bow seem a little light to use, David used a full size bow, unless he has changed over the years. He did say that all strings have to be even and played near the bridge. 

Date: Monday, March 16, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: LH 
I've done this over the years, and it can be very effective, especially for supplying sustain in ensemble arrangements. Played artfully it can take on the supply an exciting bagpipe voice or a traditional, full hurdy gurdy sound. Mary, it can really sound good beyond people's first try in a festival workshop. As with the fiddle, there is a good bit of bowing / fingering technique to practice before the tone becomes clear and sweet.  

We had a mini-course on bowing at Boone last year. Ken Bloom has developed some very effective techniques in playing the dulcimer in cello position, and has developed a dulcimer adapted for bowing, with a sound post, that sits in a stable position when played cello style. We're planning on having a bowed section of the Boone Dulcimer Orchestra this summer. Those of you that are coming and have bows, please bring them. We'll also have some if you don't.  

It's interesting to listen to Ralph Lee Smith's findings on some of the vintage dulcimers he owns. Based on the set-up and the wear of these old instruments dating back to the early 1800s, it was determined they were bowed. Jean Ritchie's "The Dulcimer Book" has an old photo of an elderly woman bowing a dulcimer.  

Date: Monday, March 16, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: RLS 
Dear Folks, 
There is evidence of a significant amount of bowing of both old dulcimers and scheitholts. In my new book, Appalachian Dulcimer Traditions, there is a picture on page 50 of a fine old 19th Century Virginia-style dulcimer with a bow. Two Virginia dulcimers in my collection came with bows. Both are illustrated in my book, The Story of the Dulcimer, page 37. John Rice Irwin's book, Musical Instruments of The Southern Appalachian Mountains, describes a lady named Dora Mullins who bowed her dulcimer (page 70).  

Bowing of scheitholts was common. Few scheitholts from Pennsylvania show the damage that inevitably results form playing this type of instrument with a striker or switch, which strongly suggests that bowing was the predominant method of play in the oldest traditions. The expanse of the body over which a striker or switch must pass before reaching the strings of most scheitholts, guarantees that this method of play will usually leave plenty of evidence. In Appalachia, the scene is more mixed -- scheitholts with damage from the action of a striker are more common. I recently acquired a nice old scheitholt from Tennessee, with replaced and broken pegs that suggests significant use. There is no striker damage. Scheitholts tend to be older than most traditional dulcimers, creating an increased likelihood of loss of the bow. A scheitholt with a bow from West Virginia is illustrated in The Story of the Dulcimer, page 19. 

Date: Monday, March 16, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: MJP 
DW wrote: It is a style that takes a lot of work to perfect. 

It sure does. And if you quit doing it for a while, you have to start all over again.  

As for the bow sizes, is up to the person. A psaltery bow seem a little light to use, David used a full size bow, unless he have changes over the years. 

It was David who suggested using a 1/2 or 3/4 size bow. It is a bit easier to handle. You can use a full size bow, but it is somewhat more awkward. You don't use the full length anyway.  

By the way, I've also found it a lot easier to place my dulcimer on a flat chair or stool in front of me rather than trying to bow it on my lap. You want to keep the bow at a right angle to the strings and that's harder on your lap, especially if you are an XL size person like me. If you let the bow start skating across the strings, you may start calling the neighborhood cats. It can make a rather annoying noise.  

Try it. It is interesting. Maybe borrow a bow from a fiddle playing friend to see if it is something you want to persue. A good bow can be a bit pricey. I feel lucky to have found a good second hand one. 

Date: Monday, March 16, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DH 
I too have attempted to learn this and found it less than fruitful as well as messy... the rosin can really gum up the strings... I did try one trick though that showed some promise... I unhooked the frog from the bow and threaded it over and under and over the three string courses and then reattached the frog to the bow... the result is a constant contact of all three strings with the bowhair and this made "shuffling" fairly easy to do... downside is no single string work is possible this rig... anyone else tried this?  

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 1998  
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: H 
Just remember a few things about the way Mark Biggs did it. He had the dulcimer on his lap with the hollow a little to the right of his leg as opposed to over it and just bowed it across the hollow. I think he used a regular size bow, although a shorter bow or a bow used on psaltry would seem better. He said you have to develop a little skill of hitting a single string, but Mark is into chords and his left hand fretted as he normally did. I have heard that old time bowers used to loosen the hair so that the hair was on the strings and the back of the bow was below the dulcimer. Seems kind of a stretch to me and would require a different real shift of position on the lap. As I remember Mark play an air or something of that nature rather than a faster tune. 

Date: Tuesday, March 17, 1998 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: RR 
MP said: Once you get a smooth action going and can play some tunes, you can try some double bowing which has a faster action on  
individual notes.  

What do you mean by double-bowing, Mary? My friend uses two bows on her psaltery, one in each hand, but you don't have frets on a psaltery. To double-bow a dulcimer from both sides that way, you'd need at least three hands for fretting and bowing! I once saw a "double bow" for a psaltery, made by Jean Schilling's dulcimer shop in Cosby TN. It was a pair of bows attached to each other, side-by-side, made for playing harmony in thirds, on two strings at once. But that still wouldn't affect the dulcimer...You've got my curiosity up!  

I frequently use a bow on my dulcimer. Several years ago I spent a week at the Boone N.C. Dulcimer Workshop in David Schnaufer's Advanced Class. It was there I learned bowing. David uses his bow more like a fiddler, on the fast tunes, while I prefer the slower tunes like "Amazing Grace" and "The Ash Grove". I prefer not to use a capo, because I love the sound of the lower notes, especially on the bass string; I call it my "lap-cello". It takes a lot of practice to learn to control the amount of pressure you exert on the bow - too little pressure and you don't get a nice clean, bright sound, while too much pressure stretches the dulcimer string and gives you the "groaning cow" or "dying cat" effect. A shorter string is tighter and does not stretch out of tune so easily. David told us he prefers to tune to DAD or DGD and then use a capo to shorten/tighten the strings, which makes for a cleaner sound when he's doing that fiddle-shuffle bowing.  

Another important part of the bowing technique I've found is that you have to fret the strings very precisely and firmly, right up next to the fret and not halfway between. Bowing is very unforgiving of careless, sloppy fretting. You CAN do "slides" with your finger from one note to another, but I use this technique sparingly for effect. You can also use vibrato, which is much easier to do if you use very thin treble strings like .09.  

What kind of bow works best? Well, when I was in David's class I bought one of the 3/4 size violin bows he was selling, but I've since discovered that I prefer a heavier wooden psaltery bow made by David Kingslake of Red Creek, WV. Unfortunately I've heard that David retired from instrument-building a while back. What a shame! His weighted bow (I think it's made of Maple?) almost plays itself! Most of the psaltery bows I've seen are very lightweight. A standard fiddle bow is SO lightweight and flexible that it is hard to control on long bowstrokes, especially when you  
get out toward the tip of the bow. As you draw the bow across the strings you have to increase the pressure to maintain an even volume. When you do this, the bow flexes, the string bends, and the pitch changes. I simply rest the horsehair of my psaltery bow across the strings and just gently push and pull it; the weight of the wooden part of the bow carries just enough pressure to create a nice clean, sweet sound with very little effort. A very short (quarter-sized?) violin bow works fairly well (I bought a nice one  
from Lorraine Lee Hammond; I think she said that she has them specially made for her.) When you give up length, though, you sacrifice those long, smooth tones you can achieve with a longer bow. Seeing the post from Ralph Lee Smith, dulcimer historian, makes me wonder, "What kind of bows did our predecessors use on their scheitholts and dulcimers?"  

Can you bow more than one string at a time? Of course! You can bow 3- or 4-note chords, or you can simulate a fiddle's arched bridge, or you can have your bridge replaced with an arched one. Lorraine Lee Hammond inserts a little L-shaped piece of wood over her flat bridge, under the middle string (or strings, for 4 equidistant string spacing), to elevate them so she can play "double-stops" (2 strings at a time) like the fiddlers do. You don't have to raise them very much, just a wee bit. I've also seen  
curved bridges on dulcimers, made specifically for bowing. Dwain Wilder of Bear Meadow Dulcimers offers this option on his instruments, and it works quite well. But I am usually content to tune to D-A-D and just bow my outside (bass and treble) strings, with an occasional 3 or 4-string chord thrown in.  

For the best sound, I try to keep my bow perpendicular to the strings, instead of at an angle to them. For a consistently good tone, I try always to bow in the same location on the strings, and not to let my bow drift up and down the fretboard.  

Bow care: I've been told that you should never put your fingers on the horsehair (or allow anyone else to "feel" it). There seems to be a universal urge to want to touch the hair and run your fingers along it. It's the first thing most people do when they pick it up. (I did!) I've learned to "snap" first "DON'T touch the hair! Please!" and then explain politely, (after they yank their fingers away, staring at you in shock,) "Sorry, didn't mean to be rude, but the natural oil on your fingers is deposited on the horsehair  
and then the resin won't stick to the hair and then the bow won't work!" The bow works because you *create* friction with the rosin so that it *drags* across the strings. Without that friction, a new or un-rosined bow slides effortlessly - and *silently* - back and forth!!! At Boone one year, one of the luthiers who makes a beautiful "electric" solid-body dulcimer  
asked me each day as I passed his table, "When are you going to bring your bow over and try it out? I'd like to hear how it sounds!" When I finally brought my bow over one afternoon, selected his fanciest instrument and sat down to play, we were both shocked to hear ... absolutely nothing! Not a sound!! It seems he had just finished rubbing all his strings with some kind of protective oil to retard tarnishing and facilitate finger-picking and doing slides. One mystery solved, and one bow temporarily out of commission! I went back to the dorm and *very* carefully shampooed and dried the hair of my bow so the resin would stick again!!  

Yes, it's true that rosin can damage the finish on your dulcimer. I use a small paintbrush or pastry brush to whisk off the loose rosin, and store my bow in a bag. I try to bow *only* over the so-called "strum hollow" of my dulcimer, so the rosin doesn't get all over my strings, my fretboard, or my fingers later on. Most people don't usually strum or fingerpick over the strum hollow anyway, they do it a little farther up the fretboard where the sound becomes "sweeter".  

A couple of folks mentioned using a playing stand or placing your dulcimer on a chair or table in front of you: A playing stand is very effective because it allows you to push the dulcimer away from you a bit and have room for a full-length bowstroke. I use a dulcimer strap around my knees for the same reason. The strap also helps to keep the dulcimer from sliding around when I put pressure on the bow.  

"Miss Lois" also mentioned Ken Bloom's Workshop last year at Boone, and the ASU Dulcimer Orchestra -- what fun we had!!! And Ken's ideas on bowing were very intriguing! I'm still experimenting with bowing in the "cello position" - nice for playing accompaniment in a group, because the instrument is upright against your shoulder, resting between your knees, and is more free to "ring out" than when it is in your lap. It is trickier to manage the fingering, however. I look forward this summer to experiencing some more of Ken's delightfully funny and unusual approaches to music, and to the mountain dulcimer.  

For those who are going to the Cranberry Dulcimer Gathering in Binghamton NY in July, on Friday I'll be conducting a workshop on "Introduction to Bowing the Mountain Dulcimer". I hope to see some of you there.  

I hope this encourages some of you to try bowing your dulcimers. Don't be put off by the discouraging comments that some have made, or even by the awful sounds you might make when you first try it. My first attempts in private usually ended very quickly; I didn't keep at it long enough to hear any improvement. My "breakthrough" came the day that I went to a jam session at our dulcimer campout in MD. I sat on the outer perimeter where I wouldn't bother anyone, and decided that I would use ONLY the bow all day, whether it was an appropriate tune or not! After sawing away for a couple of hours, it actually began to sound nice enough that I moved into the circle, and even got some compliments - I've been bowing ever since! It does take practice, but it can be very rewarding!  

Enjoy and share your musical talents!  

Date: Tuesday, March 17 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: MJP 
Wow, what a wonderful essay on bowing the dulcimer. You obviously have much more experience than I. I'll store thus away for future reference.  

As far a "double bowing", I meant the same as what you described as "fiddle shuffle bowing". 

Date: Wednesday, March 18 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: RLS 
In her fascinating posting on dulcimer bowing, RR says: Seeing the post from RLS, dulcimer historian, makes me wonder, "What kind of bows did our predecessors use on their scheitholts and dulcimers?"  

The answer is that they either used what was at hand, or made bows. "What was at hand" were fiddle bows. Fiddle bows accompanied two of the dulcimers in my collection. The bows that accompanied the West Virginia scheitholt on page 19 of The Story of the Dulcimer, and the dulcimer on page 50 of Appalachian Dulcimer Traditions are home made. 

Date: Wednesday, March 18 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DW 
Lorraine Hammond gets beautiful results with a 1/4 cello bow. See her album "Barley Break" for a sample or two. 

Date: Thursday, March 19 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DP 
DW: Don't you have a bowing bridge for your Swan model dulcimer? Tell us about it. 

Date: Thursday, March 19 
Subject: Bowing a Mountain Dulcimer 
From: DW 
DP: Yes, as RR noted, I can equip any of my dulcimers with a bowing bridge. Essentially, it is a curved bone saddle, with about 1/16" saggitta. This allows just enough room to stop the outer strings without striking the edge of the major bouts. The top of the bridge is chamfered, so that the higher strings have an additional compensation.  

Lorraine Hammond finds that she can use the bridge for fingerpicking styles too (which was a surprise to me. I thought she would find the slightly higher action on the inner two strings distracting!). She uses a 1/4 size cello bow, a Glasser fiberglass bow--nothing special, really. She likes the heft and response of this size.  

As I mentioned in a former posting on this thread, her tape, "Barley Break" contains several pieces which feature bowing. This album, by the way, is a wonderful collection of her arrangements of Elizabethan music, and came out in 1992. Quite enchanting. It is on the Yellow Moon Press label, and there is also a book of the arrangements on the tape. Both can be gotten from Lorraine, I should think. She can be contacted at dulcimer@tiac.net